The stakes are high. Among athletes under 25 who return to sport after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction, nearly one in four goes on to a second ACL injury. Wiggins et al., American Journal of Sports Medicine, 2016. This index is one of the main numbers asked to inform that return.
It also leaves a question that hop distance cannot answer: could the way an athlete lands say more about a second injury than how far they hop? Two prospective studies suggest it does. More on that below.
How do you calculate it?
| Type of test | Calculation |
|---|---|
| Distance, height or strength (more is better) | Involved limb ÷ uninvolved limb × 100 |
| Timed test (less is better) | Uninvolved limb ÷ involved limb × 100 |
Example: a single hop of 142 cm on the involved leg and 158 cm on the other gives 142 ÷ 158 × 100, or 90%.
Invert the calculation for timed tests. Otherwise a slower injured leg scores above 100%.
Which tests feed the index?
Hop tests are the most common. The founding study used four one-legged hop tests in 67 patients with a deficient anterior cruciate ligament. Half had abnormal symmetry on a single test. With two tests combined, the share rose to 62%. The authors concluded that the tests had low sensitivity and high specificity: useful to confirm a suspected deficit, weak at ruling one out. Noyes et al., American Journal of Sports Medicine, 1991.
The four tests in common use are the single hop for distance, the triple hop for distance, the crossover hop for distance and the 6-meter timed hop.
The index is also applied to quadriceps strength and to jump height.
One test is not enough. That was already the lesson in 1991.
Which threshold is used?
90% is the usual benchmark, on every test in the battery.
In a two-year cohort of 106 patients in pivoting sports after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction, passing meant scoring above 90 on all tests. Of those who failed the criteria, 38.2% were reinjured, against 5.6% of those who passed (hazard ratio 0.16, p = 0.075). Each month that return to sport was delayed, up to nine months after surgery, cut the reinjury rate by 51%. Grindem et al., British Journal of Sports Medicine, 2016.
A second cohort points the same way. Among 158 professional male athletes, those who did not meet all six discharge criteria before returning had four times the risk of a graft rupture. Kyritsis et al., British Journal of Sports Medicine, 2016.
Pooled across studies, passing a test battery came with a 60% lower risk of graft rupture, and with a higher risk of injury to the other knee. Webster and Hewett, Sports Medicine, 2019.
So the threshold earns its place, as one input to the decision. It is a convention, not a guarantee.
Where does the index mislead?
The other leg is not a fixed reference. It loses capacity during months of reduced activity. In 70 athletes tested six months after reconstruction, 57.1% reached 90% symmetry on quadriceps strength and all hop tests. Measured against the uninvolved leg before surgery, only 28.6% reached 90%. Wellsandt et al., Journal of Orthopaedic & Sports Physical Therapy, 2017.
Distance hides how the hop is done. A systematic review and meta-analysis of 19 studies found deficits in knee flexion angle and knee flexion moment during landing after reconstruction, despite adequate hop distance. Its conclusion: measuring only hop distance is insufficient to assess knee function fully. Kotsifaki et al., British Journal of Sports Medicine, 2020.
A percentage hides the absolute value. Two weak legs can be perfectly symmetrical.
The open question: can the landing predict a second injury?
Two prospective studies say the movement carries what the distance misses.
- The landing. Fifty-six athletes were assessed after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction, before returning to pivoting and cutting sports, with three-dimensional motion analysis of a drop vertical jump and a test of postural stability. Over the next 12 months, 13 of them had a second anterior cruciate ligament injury. Hip and knee mechanics during landing, together with deficits in postural stability, predicted that second injury with a sensitivity of 0.92 and a specificity of 0.88. Paterno et al., American Journal of Sports Medicine, 2010.
- A thousand athletes. In 1,045 male athletes tested nine months after reconstruction and followed for two years, strength, jump and change-of-direction results did not differ between those who reinjured the reconstructed knee and those who did not. Their movement did: the reinjured group landed differently in the drop jump and was more asymmetrical when changing direction. King et al., American Journal of Sports Medicine, 2021.
What research is working on now: turning these differences into a reliable test. In the larger study, movement measures alone identified future reinjury only moderately well, and the authors suggest that targeting them during rehabilitation may reduce the risk.
What it shows is the direction of travel: from how far an athlete hops to how they move while doing it.
How do you use it well?
- Run several tests, not one.
- Record absolute values beside the percentage: centimeters, seconds, newtons.
- Keep the protocol fixed: warm-up, number of trials, landing rule, footwear.
- Use an earlier baseline where one exists. A pre-injury or pre-surgery value of the other leg is a better reference than its value today.
- Watch the movement, not only the result. How the athlete lands is part of the finding.
- Set it beside everything else: strength, symptoms, confidence, sport-specific work, time since surgery.
A percentage does not clear an athlete. The decision is clinical.
Where does Baliston Health fit?
Side-to-side findings from hop and jump tests, in the clinic. Sensor insoles equipped with AI Mov-Scan capture the movement in suitable shoes. AI Mov-Scan captures. The platform analyzes and generates the Full Clinical Report. Balia, the platform's AI assistant, explains. The practitioner decides.
The Jump analysis covers hop and jump protocols: counter movement jump, single hop, triple hop and side hop. You review the side-to-side comparisons, the same left-against-right logic as the limb symmetry index, and follow them across sessions. You select the protocol, interpret the findings and make the return-to-sport decision.
Read about ACL recovery and return to sport and walking asymmetry, explore Baliston Health for sports medicine, or book a demo.



